When entering into a business relationship, the parties will usually go through a process of due diligence to ensure that they can have assurance that the people or organisation they are dealing with are capable of delivering what they say they plan to do.
Employers undertake their own due diligence when asking job candidates for details of who can provide a reference for their previous experience and behaviour.
You might ask a roofer to identify what work he had done on other buildings so their bona fides can be established.
Politicians seeking election set out their experience in their manifesto/promotional material and expect to be asked about that experience by the media and by individual electors.
The exception to this rule appears to be the front man for a major golf course development on the Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire, Scotland. Ask yourself if you would do business with a man with this track record.
Is it true? Note the date - April 2011. Due Diligence would establish that Donald Trump is quite quick on the draw in deploying his learned friends if he thinks he's been slighted. This article is still there 2 years later so one can only assume that Aberdeenshire Council, Scottish Enterprise, Robert Gordon University, successive First Ministers of Scotland, and many others involved in the great project Scotland didn't look very closely. Indeed it looks very much like they did not exercise due diligence.
The Menie Experience
When I watched the documentary "You've Been Trumped", I came to the conclusion that the business case for the Menie development wouldn't stand up. This blog aims to capture facts about the experience of the development of Trump International Golf Links, not opinions. If you are making comments on this blog, please note that abuse directed at individual people will be deleted.
Wednesday 10 July 2013
Monday 8 July 2013
TIGL Golfer Bookings Week Commencing 1 July 2013
Monday 1 July
- 33 golfers booked out of 60 potential
- 10 tee-time slots used from 15 available
- 41 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 12 tee-time slots used from 31 available
- 80 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 21 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 58 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 17 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 79 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 22 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 62 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 19 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 53 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 18 tee-time slots used from 33 available
For the whole week, this works out at 47.7% of golfer capacity used.
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Sunday 30 June 2013
TIGL Golfer Bookings Week Commencing 24 June 2013
The links were open from 0730 until 1530 every day - 33 available slots
of 4 golfers every quarter of an hour - except for Mondays where it
appears to start business from 12 noon - 15 available slots of 4 golfers
every quarter of an hour.
Monday 24 June
For the whole week, this works out at 47.1% of golfer capacity used.
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Monday 24 June
- 29 golfers booked out of 60 potential
- 8 tee-time slots used from 15 available
- 57 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 18 tee-time slots used from 31 available
- 96 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 26 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 94 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 26 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 71 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 23 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 34 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 11 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 20 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 7 tee-time slots used from 33 available
For the whole week, this works out at 47.1% of golfer capacity used.
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Sunday 23 June 2013
TIGL Golfer Bookings Week Commencing 17 June 2013
The links were open from 0730 until 1530 every day - 33 available slots
of 4 golfers every quarter of an hour - except for Mondays where it
appears to start business from 12 noon - 15 available slots of 4 golfers
every quarter of an hour.
Monday 17 June
For the whole week, this works out at 49.3% of golfer capacity used.
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Monday 17 June
- 28 golfers booked out of 60 potential
- 8 tee-time slots used from 15 available
- 40 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 11 tee-time slots used from 31 available
- 72 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 20 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 99 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 26 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 86 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 26 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 70 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 19 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 25 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 7 tee-time slots used from 33 available
For the whole week, this works out at 49.3% of golfer capacity used.
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Sunday 16 June 2013
TIGL Golfer Bookings Week Commencing 10 June 2013
The links were open from 0730 until 1530 every day - 33 available slots
of 4 golfers every quarter of an hour - except for Mondays where it
appears to start business from 12 noon - 15 available slots of 4 golfers
every quarter of an hour.
Monday 10 June
For the whole week, this works out at 51.6% of golfer capacity used. This was the second week in a row this season that usage capacity had appeared to go above 50%
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Monday 10 June
- 20 golfers booked out of 60 potential
- 7 tee-time slots used from 15 available
- 91 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 25 tee-time slots used from 31 available
- 20 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 7 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 41 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 12 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 107 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 28 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 77 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 21 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 84 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 23 tee-time slots used from 33 available
For the whole week, this works out at 51.6% of golfer capacity used. This was the second week in a row this season that usage capacity had appeared to go above 50%
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Monday 10 June 2013
TIGL Golfer Bookings Week Commencing 3 June 2013
The links were open from 0730 until 1530 every day - 33 available slots
of 4 golfers every quarter of an hour - except for Mondays where it
appears to start business from 12 noon - 15 available slots of 4 golfers
every quarter of an hour.
Thursday and Friday of this week coincided with the visit of Donald J Trump to hold a press conference about his plans for building a second course at Menie
Monday 3 June
Friday 7 June
For the whole week, this works out at 58.1% of golfer capacity used. This was by far the busiest week of the season to date, and the first time usage capacity had appeared to go above 50%
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Thursday and Friday of this week coincided with the visit of Donald J Trump to hold a press conference about his plans for building a second course at Menie
Monday 3 June
- 33 golfers booked out of 60 potential
- 11 tee-time slots used from 15 available
- 28 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 9 tee-time slots used from 31 available
- 79 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 22 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 125 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 32 tee-time slots used from 33 available
Friday 7 June
- 105 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 27 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 77 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 22 tee-time slots used from 33 available
- 48 golfers booked out of 132 potential;
- 14 tee-time slots used from 33 available
For the whole week, this works out at 58.1% of golfer capacity used. This was by far the busiest week of the season to date, and the first time usage capacity had appeared to go above 50%
[All data transcribed from TIGL online booking tool the evening before. Casual on the day bookings not therefore captured; all golfers assumed to have turned up. Cannot guarantee that all paid for their rounds]
Turning it up to 11
The spoof rock music documentary This is Spinal Tap had many memorable goofy moments, not least when guitarist
Nigel Tufnel explained that his amplifier was louder because it went
up to, not just ten, but eleven.
The Menie Dunes witnessed a similar
moment last week when Donald J Trump outlined his plans for building
a second golf course.
At the end of the press conference,
Joseph Cinque, President of the American Academy of HospitalitySciences, gave Donald Trump their Six Star Diamond Award for Best
Golf Course Worldwide 2013.
Six Stars? I thought they only went up to Five? On this, Wikipedia notes “As
no traditional organization or formal body awards or recognizes any
rating over five-star deluxe, such claims are meaningless”.
Six
Stars is the same as turning it up to 11.
As of much relevance is the fact that
one of the principal Trustees of the American Academy of Hospitality
Sciences is its Ambassador Extraordinaire - Donald J Trump. Honorary Trustees include Donald's
two sons, and the Trustees include Trump's Chief Operating Officer. A complete coincidence, no doubt.
The Scotsman and the Herald newspapers covered Trump's receipt of this “turned up to 11” award
without any reference to this coincidence. Congratulations through
to the Daily Record for seeing through this scam and explaining that
Trump is pictured next to Cinque on the Trustees page of the
“Academy's” internet site.
Perhaps the Daily Record can run some training events on using internet search engines for staff at the Scotsman and The Herald. This demonstrates a lack of questioning of Trump Press Releases and Lines by the Scottish Press and more widely. And it also suggests that the Trump organisation, by engaging in what is basically a scam, is contemptuous of the people they are dealing with in Aberdeenshire (as well as recognising the inability of the media to ask questions beyond what is presented to them).
Perhaps the Daily Record can run some training events on using internet search engines for staff at the Scotsman and The Herald. This demonstrates a lack of questioning of Trump Press Releases and Lines by the Scottish Press and more widely. And it also suggests that the Trump organisation, by engaging in what is basically a scam, is contemptuous of the people they are dealing with in Aberdeenshire (as well as recognising the inability of the media to ask questions beyond what is presented to them).
A kind commenter on the Scotsman story has found a five-year old item giving some more alleged background on the relationship between Cinque and Trump, which you may read here if you wish.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)